“How can you say addiction isn’t a disease? You ever see someone come off of heroin?”
“Heavy drinkers are dependent on booze – obviously that’s a disease!”
“What about drunks who get cirrhosis of the liver – that’s a disease too!”
We get questions like this all the time. Unfortunately, these statements take the already controversial theory – the disease of addiction/alcoholism – and make it even more difficult to understand or debunk. Physical withdrawal and cirrhosis are important to understand because each plays a role in the overall tapestry of the habit of heavy drinking and/or drugging. But while they play a role, the existence of them is not proof of a disease of addiction or “alcoholism”.
There are two things happening in the statements made above that deserve initial clarity. First, they assume at the onset that addiction and/or heavy drinking is a disease (it’s not). Secondly, they are using the existence of other physical diseases that are the result of heavy substance use, such as cirrhosis or pancreatitis, as proof of the disease of addiction, as well as physical withdrawal symptoms as further proof of the disease. But here is the problem, and it’s a big one; when these assertions are made they ignore the fact that the supposed disease of addiction has its origins in the mind, not in the body. When we all think about the disease of addiction, we think things like the following:
“Joe just couldn’t say no to the vodka.”
“Tammy lost her kids because she loved crack more than her children.”
These are descriptions of habits of the heart and mind, not habits driven by body chemistry. Even when referring to the most extreme brain disease theory centered around biochemical “causes of addiction”, the argument is still tied to, “the person just cannot say no to using/drinking.” So you see, no matter how you slice it, whether you have pancreatitis, cirrhosis, a brain disease, or massive DT’s from withdrawal, you still have to decide to put a bottle to your lips or a needle in your arm. In the disease theory, the purported inability to choose to say no is what is meant by the “disease of addiction” or “alcoholism”. This supposed inability is based on the theory that substance users are afflicted with a mental craving for substances that they cannot control. This theory is dreadfully wrong and has been debunked over and over again over the last 70 years, yet our society has doubled down on it and its support of it – the facts be damned!
For the purposes of this article I’m not going to make the argument that drug addiction is not a disease and neither is heavy drinking, as that is covered in many of my previous articles and books. If you want to know more about the debunked disease theory of addiction, read The Freedom Model for Addictions, Escape the Treatment and Recovery Trap. All of the evidence debunking this theory is there for you in one place. In short, the disease of addiction or alcoholism as defined as a lack of control, a mental disorder, a mental defect, or a compulsion, is false.
Withdrawal – Proof of a Disease?
This brings us to the question, does alcohol or drug withdrawal compel (mentally and emotionally) a person to drink or drug beyond their will? Does a physical condition that requires hospitalization or a clinic-driven physical detoxification process cause someone or compel them to continue to use substances? The simple answer is no, it does not, or none of these people would ever stop, but they do. Over 90% of people eventually overcome their alcohol problems, and more than 95% overcome their drug problems.
Can relief of withdrawal pain be a potent personal motivation for continuing heavy use? Of course. But can it compel people to use? No. Most opioid users have gone through withdrawal cold turkey. Most people with alcohol problems have done it cold turkey too, though some need medical help to deal with potentially fatal symptoms. If it were genuinely compelling, those folks would walk right back out of the detox clinic and get a drink. But they choose to stay. There is no mysterious force within a toxified human body that forces a person to drink or drug. However, making the decision to stave off the pain of withdrawal with further use is a choice that isn’t all that unusual or in any way a disorder-driven event. We “kick the can” down the road to avoid pain and suffering all the time in the human condition for a variety of personal reasons. Whether or not avoiding withdrawal with continued use is a good choice or not doesn’t mean it isn’t chosen.
Other Diseases – Proof of an Addiction Disorder or Disease?
Let’s look at cirrhosis. Does the presence of this life threatening liver disease mean the decision to drink is compelled or forced upon people that have it by a mysterious mental force over which they have no control? That is what the following assertion states:
“What about drunks who get cirrhosis of the liver – it’s a disease!”
So is the presence of liver disease proof that the disease of alcoholism exists? At a glance, you might think so. First off, we can all agree with a part of the statement; cirrhosis is a disease, that’s a fact. But that isn’t what is being inferred in that statement. What they are trying to argue is that the result of drinking (the physical disease of cirrhosis) is the cause (the mental disease of alcoholism) of the individual’s drinking habit. Frankly this idea is nonsensical. It’s an illogical reverse argument, a sort of “guilt by association” attempt to prove that drinking itself is an involuntary behavior.
When using cirrhosis (or any other alcohol related physical illness) as an example to prop up the addiction disease ideal, you are conflating the physical ramifications of choosing to drink heavily as proof that the person had no choice in drinking on the front end. At best, this is a strange argument. It’s akin to a boxer who just lost to a knock-out saying in his post-fight press conference, “I got knocked out! Obviously I was forced beyond my will to take the fight and get in the ring!”
The confusion behind self-destructive habits such as heavy drug and alcogol use is deep enough without adding to the mix parallel disease and withdrawal arguments. People use heavily for personal reasons, and when they do so, other costs come down the road. Some heavy drinkers may get cirrhosis or pancreatitis while others may get life threatening withdrawal symptoms when they stop drinking. Yet, simply stated, these are the results of heavy use, not the causes of them. The causes are in the mind of the individual. It’s in our likes and desires, not in our biochemistry. And while the costs of these habits might be high, that fact doesn’t mean the use is compelled – it just means the person felt the trade-offs were worth it. There is a way to get beyond this, and it’s not by pretending that substance use is an involuntary behavior. It’s by facing your options, reassessing them, and making a heartfelt decision to change.
If you want to know more about becoming free from cravings, you can get your own free copy of The Freedom Model for Addictions, Escape the Treatment and Recovery Trap at www.thefreedommodel.org/products/ and use the coupon code FREEDOM108 at checkout. For The Freedom Model for the Family use coupon code FAMILY100 at checkout.
Or call 888-424-2626 for help with your addiction.
If you would like to get away and learn the Freedom Model with a certified FM Instructor in a residential retreat setting at The Saint Jude Retreat, call the number above, or go to www.soberforever.net
If you want to learn about The Freedom Model Private Instruction Program, a program you take from the safety and comfort of home, go to www.leaveaddictionbehind.com
Mr. Mark Scheeren is the Co-Founder and Chairman of the St. Jude Retreat, as is co-author of The Freedom Model for Addictions, Escape the Treatment and Recovery Trap, the original Non-12-Step approach for people who struggle with serious substance use issues. Mr. Scheeren and his staff of Researchers and Instructors have helped many thousands find permanent solutions to their drug and alcohol problems.
You CAN Move Past an Addiction
…a message to those who feel hopeless
There is a difference between struggling “one day at a time” in recovery and moving on from an addiction; there’s a big difference. We’ve been taught that once you’re an addict, you’ll always be an addict. This is not true. However, should you believe this, it becomes your truth. But it doesn’t have to be that way. So called addicts and alcoholics moderate their use with surprising frequency (for example, 50% of all “alcoholics” eventually moderate their drinking to non-problematic levels whether they’ve been treated or not – NESARC, 2005). While the facts are what they are – and they are very encouraging – people are woefully ignorant of these hopeful and empowering facts. Here’s the truth; beliefs can change; and lives change when our beliefs do. Once I realized I’d been lied to and I found that alcohol and drugs were not the “cunning, baffling, powerful” agents they were said to be, I could easily choose better for myself. I didn’t need extra willpower, more strength, or any kind of special recovery formula once I realized that drugs were substances, not living, breathing, motivated entities bent on my destruction. This bizarre and fictitious personified view of drugs as an all-powerful entity was one of the myths that caused me to fear them, and in turn, I feared the inevitable “triggered relapse” as well. That’s what fear based mythology can do. It keeps you trapped in the relapse loop. Even the word “relapse” makes a connotation to the “disease of addiction” myth. There are dozens of ways the treatment and recovery models have instilled this myth based fear throughout its messaging. The question is why? Treatment and Recovery are about Control It’s all about control. A free thinking, freely choosing individual cannot be controlled because the center of that individual’s…
Am I An Addict?
Objective Truth vs. Subjective ‘Truth’
With so much talk about heavy substance use increasing as a result of the pandemic lockdowns, there are many people wondering if they may have crossed the line from reasonable substance use to “addiction”. Rates of serious emotional problems such as depression and anxiety are skyrocketing across the country as a result of people being locked in their homes and many are using alcohol and other drugs to try and get some relief. But is this increasing demographic now officially suffering from addiction? Are these millions of people now doomed to lifetime of addiction treatment, meetings, and perpetual struggle? Let me answer this straight – absolutely not. In the book, The Freedom Model for Addictions, Escape the Treatment and Recovery Trap, we discuss the concept of addiction as the following: The very concept of addiction – whether it’s called a disease, a disorder, or something else – says that some people (i.e. “addicts & alcoholics”) are enslaved to the behavior of substance use in some way. That is, they cross some line where they are no longer actively choosing to use substances of their own free will, but instead are compelled to use substances. It’s also said that they are unable to stop themselves from using once they start (they experience a loss of control); that they are unable to stop wanting to use substances (they experience craving); that all of this just happens without their consent (that they’re triggered by various things and feelings); and finally, that they’re in for a lifetime of struggling with their demons (the “chronic relapsing disease” and “ongoing recovery.”) This definition is a construct of the treatment industry – in other words, it’s made up. But because it has been repeated for nearly eight decades, it has become truth to believers. I was once…
Big Court Win Involving Ballot Evidence Could Potentially Swing Nevada to Trump (Details)
Democrat Denver Mayor Leaving Town for Thanksgiving, But Told Residents to Stay Put
They keep getting caught!
11th Circuit Court of Appeals Grants Trump Attorney’s Appeal In Georgia — Details
A much needed win!
Former NSA Michael Flynn Has Officially Been Pardoned By President Trump [Details]
Lefties to flip in 3...2...1...
Schaftlein Report: What Do Giuliani, Powell & Jenna Ellis Have Up Their Sleeves? (Video)
Best of the Week
News4 days ago
Big News About Georgia Election Set to Drop In Coming Days: It ‘Will Be Shocking!’
News6 days ago
Trump Supporters Must Be ‘Deprogrammed’ According to Democrat National Committee Member
News5 days ago
NFL Quarterback’s Wife Issues Apology After Saying Michigan Is A ‘Dictatorship’ Under Whitmer
News4 days ago
People Who Don’t Wear Masks Should Be ‘Hanging’ or Imprisoned Says ‘Harry Potter’ Star
News5 days ago
17-Year-Old Kyle Rittenhouse Released From Jail On $2 Million Bail — Details
News6 days ago
Kids ‘Safest’ From COVID-19 In Schools, Shutting Down Is ‘Emotional’ & Not Data-Based
News4 days ago
No Arrests Made After Over 100 Antifa Rioters Vandalize Portland Buildings — Details
News4 days ago
Trump: COVID-19 Vaccine Was Purposely Delayed By Big Pharma Until After Election Day
News4 days ago
Poll: Half of All Americans, 1/3 of Democrats Believe Election Was Stolen From Trump
News5 days ago
Flashback: Elected Official Says Communism Is Coming to Denver By ‘Any Means Necessary’
News5 days ago
Health Secretary of Pennsylvania Predicts We’ll Be Wearing Masks Through End of 2021
News3 days ago
Democrat Governor Confronted At Restaurant for Not Wearing Mask, Not Distancing (Video)